Charles Smith Rutherford: Canada's Fearless WWI Hero

There are men who answer the call and then there are the few who redefine what it means to run toward the fire. Lieutenant Charles Smith Rutherford was one of them. Farmer. Warrior. Reluctant hero. The kind of man who didn’t need to talk about courage, he just showed you what it looked like.

Born January 9th, 1892, in the small Ontario town of Colborne, Rutherford grew up with calloused hands and a clear sense of duty. His roots were in the soil, but his spirit was forged for something harder, something far beyond the family farm. When war broke out across Europe and the call went out for Canadian men to serve, Rutherford didn’t hesitate. He signed up in March 1916, just another farm boy heading off to fight in someone else’s war.

But Charles Rutherford wasn’t “just another” anything.

THE WESTERN FRONT – BLOOD, MUD, AND THE MAKING OF A WARRIOR

Rutherford joined the 83rd Battalion, and from there, shipped out to Europe where he was assigned to the 5th Canadian Mounted Rifles. This wasn’t glamorous cavalry work. This was trench warfare. Death, mud, rats, and wire, where valor lived side by side with horror.

By 1917, Rutherford had already been wounded. Twice. But both times, he fought his way back to the front. And when the orders came to push through hell, he didn’t flinch. At Passchendaele, a name that still stinks of blood and swamp, he earned the Military Medal for pure guts. It was a place where men drowned in craters, and machine guns shredded hope. Rutherford kept going. When the world was falling apart, he held the line.

Command took notice. He was a natural leader. Calm under fire. Precise. Relentless.

They pulled him from the trenches and sent him for officer training. In April 1918, now a Lieutenant, Rutherford returned to the fight. And it was only just beginning.

AUGUST 26, 1918 – THE DAY HE FACED DEATH ALONE

During the Hundred Days Offensive, Canadian troops were spearheading the Allied advance. The Germans were on their heels, but still dangerous, desperate men with machine guns and concrete pillboxes guarding every inch.

That morning, near Monchy-le-Preux, France, Rutherford was leading an assault party. But as the battle kicked off, he found himself well ahead of his men. Alone. Out in front. Just him… and a heavily armed German pillbox.

Most men would fall back. Wait for support. Maybe call in an artillery strike.

Not Rutherford.

With his revolver drawn, he walked right up to the pillbox and signaled for the enemy to surrender. Bold? Yes. Insane? Maybe. But somehow, the Germans bought it. They thought he had an entire company behind him.

Forty-five German soldiers, including two officers and three machine guns, laid down their weapons. One man. One revolver. Forty-five prisoners. No shots fired.

And he wasn’t done yet.

FOLLOW ME, OR DIE

Rutherford then convinced one of the captured German officers to order another enemy machine gun position to stand down. And they did.

But when he saw another one of his assault parties pinned down, caught in a crossfire from a second pillbox, Rutherford snapped back into action. He grabbed a Lewis gun team, stormed the position, and captured another 35 prisoners, plus their weapons.

In less than a day, Charles Smith Rutherford neutralized two enemy pillboxes, captured 80 prisoners, and cleared the way for the Canadian advance.

Not bad for a farm boy from Ontario.

For his actions, he was awarded the Victoria Cross, the highest military honor in the British Commonwealth. His citation called him “bold and gallant,” and said his example “inspired all ranks in the assault.”

The truth?

Rutherford didn’t inspire people with speeches. He inspired them by doing the impossible and making it look easy.

AFTER THE WAR – SERVICE DIDN’T END

After being demobilized in 1919, Rutherford returned home to Canada and resumed his life as a farmer. In 1921, married Margaret Helen Haig and had a son Andrew John Rutherfold. And tried to live a normal life.

But you don’t walk away from war unchanged.

In 1934, he became Sergeant-at-Arms at the Ontario Legislature. And in true Rutherford fashion, he made history again, becoming the first man in the role to physically eject a politician from the chamber. Protocol mattered. So did respect.

Then World War II hit. And once again, Rutherford raised his hand. He joined the Veterans Guard of Canada, serving with honor into his fifties. Promoted to Captain, he helped guard prisoners of war and protect key infrastructure at home.

Even in peacetime, he kept serving.

THE FINAL SALUTE

Charles Smith Rutherford died on June 11, 1989. He was 97 years old, and the last surviving Canadian Victoria Cross recipient from the First World War.

He’s buried in Colborne Union Cemetery, not far from where he grew up. No fanfare. No grand monuments. Just a quiet grave for a man who changed the course of battle with nothing but nerve and a sidearm.

Rutherford never wrote a book. Never sold his story. He didn’t need to.

Because for the men who stood beside him, and the enemies who surrendered before him, his story was already legend.

Charles Smith Rutherford.Canadian. Warrior.Unshakable. Unbreakable.And, like all true heroes… humble to the end.

Follow us on instagram and facebook for more content on Canada's War History.

Instagram

Facebook